For those who've completed Shivering Isles:

Did you just forrest gump your way through the Light the Flame of Agnon Quest? Or did you have a reason for your choice?

I like both for different reasons, so don't know what's best, and I don't know what the ramifications of choosing are, either.


So Saints or Seducers? I guess I'm kind of leaning more to the Seducers, so much more fun than Saints.

I pretended to be on the Saints side and led them into an ambush by the Seducers.I liked the Seducers,they just seemed to be a little less arrogant than the Saints.Also i liked the Seducer armor.lol

theres only one choise for me....seduction, go figure!

I went with the seducers as well, but I merely joined in the deffense - less work, more shooting at deffenseless saint from up high.

But I placed the flame on the mania side afterwards.. you know, As a sacrifice of sorts . I didn't realy want to choose sides - I didn't want to do that at all.

I chose the seducers because saint were all like "Hollier than thou". Which kinda rilled me.

I went with the Saints, as I play an Aureal in my game. Actually, in my Oblivion world, I am the King of the Aureals.

... After all, it is Fantasy

... to actually answer your question, I believe the Saints to be a more honorable and loyal race.

I aided the Seducers, because the Saints were always extremely rude. "Speak quickly!" "...Go!" like you're something unpleasant they found stuck to the bottom of their shoe, while the Seducers were very friendly and helpful; "How may I serve?" and "Walk with our lord." I went to them, dropped Sheogorath's name, and they fell over themselves to help me take care of business. Even though I'm more partial to Mania than Dementia, those Saints really rub me the wrong way.

Oh, and as for consequences, you will get the ability to summon a seducer guard when you complete the quest for the seducers, or a saint if you do it for the saints. But if you really like the summons, you may wish to pick the opposite side this time around, because later in the main quest you'll have to aid the opposite side, and you'll be given a LONGER summon for them.

Hey, you guys are pretty helpful!

I really appreciate all your thoughts!

I chose Mania from personal experience. Being on both sides of mania and depression of mentality. I have to say mania is much more fun.

Happy... happy... joy... joy!

I did as well choose for Mania, because it looked much more optimistic... and helped the Saints.
As an end reward I got a longer summon for a Dark Seducer Guard, as stated before by Tchos.

With my new character I will be helping the other side, so I get a longer Golden Saint (Aurial) summon.