I occasionally visit this site for mods since the selection is quite vast, and there are a number I've been able to find here that aren't over at my usual spot (planetelderscrolls). With that said, I do have a number of things that I've found bug me a little each time I visit.
First off, I don't log in before I actually browse for mods - or often times I'll be linked directly to a mod page from a google search. In these cases, when I go to download (and the mod is over the size limit) it will ask me to login. That's fine, but after I login I'm sent back to the main mod page - and I have to navigate back to the mod.
So I use the handy search button that's right there. Type in the name of the mod I'm looking for, but that seems to direct me to another page with a more detailed search description, and not any actual search. It's a little thing that could be user error, but is still a little frustrating.
So I enter the name again in the new search engine, come up with the mod I'm looking for, and download. It'd be much easier if after you logged in, you are returned to the page you came from (the mod you attempted to download and needed to login), rather than be thrown back to the beginning.
Also, since I do visit this site infrequently, I seem to always forget my password! Well, sort of. I have two handles that I use for all my sites, and two passwords to go with those handles (with number variations for sites that require em). It's complex, but I can usually figure out what goes where with a few tries, or retrieve the password. Well, I was trying my combinations that I thought I had used at this site, but it wasn't working - so I went to the password retrieval option.
Here's where I think you should have the person enter their email address as opposed to their username - or maybe in addition to. Mainly being because I do use two handles for site logins, and when retrieving my password, you only ask for the username. So in theory I could be queing a password retrieval for someones else account if they have one of the names I regularly use!
The other problem came in that after I hit the "retrieve" button for both my usernames, I wasn't recieving any email! I tried this a few days ago, and never received anything.
I thought to myself that maybe I had used an obscure email to register to prevent spam. Thats ok, that would be my fault, I'll just re-register using my normal email. Unfortunately when I tried to register again, it said that email address was already in use. So that means that my email address wasn't incorrect in my login, but I still wasn't receiving any response to my retrievals.
So finally I re-registered with yet another email. In the end now I have this account with one email, and another account with another email that I can't seem to access or retrieve my info for.
Finally, when browsing mods in the mod area, I'll click on a mod - view the description, decide I don't want it, and push my "back" button. Only for me it doesn't go back, it just reloads the same page. Not sure why that is. I have to manually go back and look at my back-history, and select the previous page I want to go to. I'm using the latest IE if that helps, and it doesnt happen at any other site. I haven't tested this in Firefox.
So the three things that seem to irk me are:
- Login sending you to main page, and not last page viewed
- Retrieve Password function (include email with username)
- Back button being wonky
If I were a regular user, I'm sure my opinion would be far different as I'd probably be logging in ahead of time, figure out what settings I need to tweak to make the back button work, and I wouldnt need to retrieve my password. However, because I'm not a regular user, the experiences here leave me a little annoyed and not very interested in
becoming a regular user.
In the end I wrote this because I had a frustrating experience and needed to vent, and happened to see this thread on the main page, so I thought I'd share my experience. This isn't a bash of the site, I think it serves a great purpose and has a good selection of mods, but it's not the easiest to visit for me (a 2-3 times a month visitor).